Simeon's "Sign that Should Be Contradicted," Applied to the Heretical Gainsaying of the True Birth of Christ. One of the Heretics' Paradoxes Turned in Support of Catholic Truth

We acknowledge, however, that the prophetic declaration of Simeon is fulfilled, which he spoke over the recently-born Saviour:⁷²⁵⁰ "Behold, this child is set for the fall and rising again of many in Israel, and for a sign that shall be spoken against."⁷²⁵¹ The sign (here meant) is that of the birth of Christ, according to Isaiah: "Therefore the Lord Himself shall give you a sign: behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son."⁷²⁵² We discover, then, what the sign is which is to be spoken against—the conception and the parturition of the Virgin Mary, concerning which these sophists⁷²⁵³ say: "She a virgin and yet not a virgin bare, and yet did not bear;" just as if such language, if indeed it must be uttered, would not be more suitable even for ourselves to use! For "she bare," because she produced offspring of her own flesh and "yet she did not bear," since she produced Him not from a husband's seed; she was "a virgin," so far as (abstinence) from a husband went, and "yet not a virgin," as regards her bearing a child. There is not, however, that parity of reasoning which the heretics affect: in other words it does not follow that for the reason "she did not bear,"⁷²⁵⁴ she who was "not a virgin" was "yet a virgin," even because she became a mother without any fruit of her own womb. But with us there is no equivocation, nothing twisted into a double sense.⁷²⁵⁵ Light is light; and darkness, darkness; yea is yea; and nay, nay; "whatsoever is more than these cometh of evil."⁷²⁵⁶ She who bare (really) bare; and although she was a virgin when she conceived, she was a wife⁷²⁵⁷ when she brought forth her son. Now, as a wife, she was under the very law of "opening the womb,"⁷²⁵⁸ wherein it was quite immaterial whether the birth of the male was by virtue of a husband's co-operation or not;⁷²⁵⁹ it was the same sex⁷²⁶⁰ that opened her womb. Indeed, hers is the womb on account of which it is written of others also: "Every male that openeth the womb shall be called holy to the Lord."⁷²⁶¹ For who is really holy but the Son of God? Who properly opened the womb but He who opened a closed one?⁷²⁶² But it is marriage which opens the womb in all cases. The virgin's womb, therefore, was especially⁷²⁶³ opened, because it was especially closed. Indeed⁷²⁶⁴ she ought rather to be called not a virgin than a virgin, becoming a mother at a leap, as it were, before she was a wife. And what must be said more on this point? Since it was in this sense that the apostle declared that the Son of God was born not of a virgin, but "of a woman," he in that statement recognised the condition of the "opened womb" which ensues in marriage.⁷²⁶⁵ We read in Ezekiel of "a heifer⁷²⁶⁶ which brought forth, and still did not bring forth." Now, see whether it was not in view of your own future contentions about the womb of Mary, that even then the Holy Ghost set His mark upon you in this passage; otherwise⁷²⁶⁷ He would not, contrary to His usual simplicity of style (in this prophet), have uttered a sentence of such doubtful import, especially when Isaiah says, "She shall conceive and bear a son."⁷²⁶⁸

Chapter XXIV.—Divine Strictures on Various Heretics Descried in Various Passages of Prophetical Scripture. Those Who Assail the True Doctrine of the One Lord Jesus Christ, Both God and Man, Thus Condemned.

For when Isaiah hurls denunciation against our very heretics, especially in his "Woe to them that call evil good, and put darkness for light,"⁷²⁶⁹ he of course sets his mark upon those amongst you⁷²⁷⁰ who preserve not in the words they employ the light of their true significance, (by taking care) that the soul should mean only that which is so called, and the flesh simply that which is confest to our view, and God none other than the One who is preached.⁷²⁷¹ Having thus Marcion in his prophetic view, he says, "I am God, and there is none else; there is no God beside me."⁷²⁷² And when in another passage he says, in like manner, "Before me there was no God,"⁷²⁷³ he strikes at those inexplicable genealogies of the Valentinian Æons. Again, there is an answer to Ebion in the Scripture: "Born,⁷²⁷⁴ not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God." In like manner, in the passage, "If even an angel of heaven preach unto you any other gospel than that which we have preached unto you, let him be anathema,"⁷²⁷⁵ he calls attention to the artful influence of Philumene,⁷²⁷⁶ the virgin friend of Apelles. Surely he is antichrist who denies that Christ has come in the flesh.⁷²⁷⁷ By declaring that His flesh is simply and absolutely true, and taken in the plain sense of its own nature, the Scripture aims a blow at all who make distinctions in it.⁷²⁷⁸ In the same way, also, when it defines the very Christ to be but one, it shakes the fancies of those who exhibit a multiform Christ, who make Christ to be one being and Jesus another,—representing one as escaping out of the midst of the crowds, and the other as detained by them; one as appearing on a solitary mountain to three companions, clothed with glory in a cloud, the other as an ordinary man holding intercourse with all,⁷²⁷⁹ one as magnanimous, but the other as timid; lastly, one as suffering death, the other as risen again, by means of which event they maintain a resurrection of their own also, only in another flesh. Happily, however, He who suffered "will come again from heaven,"⁷²⁸⁰ and by all shall He be seen, who rose again from the dead. They too who crucified Him shall see and acknowledge Him; that is to say, His very flesh, against which they spent their fury, and without which it would be impossible for Himself either to exist or to be seen; so that they must blush with shame who affirm that His flesh sits in heaven void of sensation, like a sheath only, Christ being withdrawn from it; as well as those who (maintain) that His flesh and soul are just the same thing,⁷²⁸¹ or else that His soul is all that exists,⁷²⁸² but that His flesh no longer lives.